Juan Pollo Potato Salad Recipe

This post may contain affiliate links. I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. All opinions remain my own.

Latest posts by Grace (see all)

Including potatoes in your daily diet is beneficial as they are considered one of the most nutritious foods.

Thick creamy potato salad is a delicious meal you can serve as a side dish.

Make some crispy fried or grilled chicken and serve with chilled potato salad.

You will enjoy the savory chicken flavor and creamy potato salad.

What is potato salad?

Potato salad contains boiled potatoes, vegetables, and other ingredients.

You can serve it with the main meal as a side dish.

The potato salad was originally German cuisine but is now widely spread in Europe, Asia, Japan, and the United States.

.Juan Pollo, a restaurant in southern California, serves the best Potato salad.

Their potato salad is creamy and tasty, made with mayonnaise and sour cream.

This article is the ultimate guide on making Juan Pollo potato salad and more.

Three Juan Callo Potatoes salad recipes

Recipe 1- The traditional potato salad

Tricks and tips

Use mayonnaise or salad dressing; both are creamy and thick. You can add some Dijon mustard to make your sauce lighter.


Serve your potato salad chilled.


You can add salami, pepperoni, ham, or bacon to your potato salad to make it tastier.


Experiment with pickles, capers, or olive for a creamy potato salad.


Try using fresh herbs like parsley, oregano thyme, and basil to give your potato salad an original taste.


Find the best potatoes to use; try Klondike Goldust potatoes or Yukon gold.


Start boiling the potatoes in cold salty water to make sure they cook evenly.



Sliced onions


Chopped black olives


Chopped onions




Unpeeled potatoes






Black pepper


Sour cream



1.Wash the unpeeled potatoes and boil them in salted water.


2.Drain the water once the potatoes are tender.


3.Let your potatoes cool for a few minutes, then peel.


4.Slice the potatoes and put them on a plate.


5.Put the parsley, mayonnaise, onions, salt, and black pepper in a bowl and mix.


6.Add vinegar and cream as you mix until it’s soft.


7.Pour the mixture on your potatoes and let it rest a few minutes, then serve.


Recipe 2- Spicy potato salad with eggs




Celery (seeds)




Black pepper


●Boiled and chopped eggs


Apple cider vinegar






Fresh dill(chopped)


Celery (stalks)




Fresh potatoes(unpeeled)


Yellow mustard



1.Wash the unpeeled potatoes and boil them in salted water.


2.Drain the water once the potatoes are ready.


3.Let your potatoes cool for a few minutes, then peel


4.Slice the potatoes and put them on a plate.


5.Make your salad dressing-mix the chopped boiled eggs. Mayonnaise, mustard, celery(seeds and stalks), onions, pickles, fresh dill, vinegar in a bowl, and add the spices last while you combine.


6.Add the salad dressing to your potatoes while they are still warm


7.Serve and enjoy.


.Note: This potato salad tastes better when served a day later; you can store it in the fridge then consume it a day later.

Recipe 3- a classic potato salad




Lemon juice




Chives (chopped)


Kosher salt


Chopped pickles




Black pepper


Dijon mustard


Finely chopped onions


Fresh Potatoes


●Boiled and chopped eggs



1.Boil the potatoes in water until cooked.


2.Drain the water and leave it to cool.


3.Make the salad dressing (combine onions, mayonnaise, paprika, lemon juice, pickles, and dijon mustard.)


4.Mix the boiled potatoes with eggs, then add chives.


5.Pour your salad dressing on the potato mixture.


6.Serve with lettuce.


Meals to serve with potato salad

Turkey sandwich

Pair a turkey sandwich with potato salad to make your meal complete.

Turkey sandwich is delicious, quick, and easy to make; serve with potato salad, and enjoy.

Potato salad with a turkey sandwich makes a healthy meal instead of fries.


Serve potato salad with your favorite burgers like veggie or bacon.

Add mustard flavor to your potato salad and serve with a veggie burger.


Try grilled chicken wings or crispy fried chicken in mustard with potato salad.

Chicken, whichever way it’s cooked, blends well with potato salad flavor.

You will enjoy the sour, creamy taste of potato salad and crispy fried chicken dripping with mustard.

Barbecue pork ribs

Imagine the taste of sweet, savory ribs with chilled potato salad.

Ribs in barbecue sauce blend so well with creamy potato salad.

Squeeze some lemon juice on your ribs and dip in chilled potato salad.

Baked beans

This combination is best for vegetarians.

Baked beans and potato salad flavors complement each other well; you will not regret it.

Spice up your baked beans for a rich flavor with your potato salad.


Steak is the best meal to serve when hosting that backyard party.

Grilled steak with chilled potato salad is an excellent meal combination.


Coleslaw brings this vibrant, beautiful color to your dining table.

Serve it with potato salad; the flavors blend in so well.

Coleslaws’ attractive look equally matches the flavor.

How to freeze and thaw potato salad

Potato salad is a very delicate meal when it comes to storage.

You will need to be very careful with how long you leave it at room temperature.

Always keep it chilled in the fridge unless you want to consume it.

The mayonnaise and eggs could quickly grow bacteria making it poisonous.

Here are instructions on how to freeze and thaw your potato salad:

You will need an airtight container to prevent moisture and freezer burn that can ruin the flavor of your potato salad.


Once you put potato salad in the container, leave a little space to allow expansion when it freezes.


Put your container in the freezer and label it.


You can freeze potato salad for up to three months


Thaw your potato salad in the refrigerator overnight to consume; never thaw it at room temperature.


.Health benefits of potato salad


Potatoes contain vitamin C, which is rich in collagen.

Vitamin C is an antioxidant that protects your skin from damage caused by pollution and the sun; it also keeps your skin moisturized, smooth, and wrinkle-free.

Improves digestion

Potatoes are high in fiber which promotes a healthy digestive system.

Daily intake of fiber prevents constipation and bloating.

Improved heart health

Potatoes do not contain cholesterol which is good for your heart health.

Potato salads contain vitamin B6, potassium, fiber, and vitamin C, essential for a healthy heart.

Fiber helps lower cholesterol in the blood, reducing heart disease risk.

Improved bone health

Potato salad contains minerals like magnesium, zinc, calcium, iron, and phosphorus that help our bodies maintain and build a healthy bone structure.

Zinc and iron contain collagen, a critical component for bone formation and structure.

Reduced inflammation

Potatoes contain choline, an excellent mineral for proper and better brain function.

This mineral is essential for:





Maintaining cellular membrane structure


Absorption of fat


Muscle movement


Brain development in children




Transmission of nerve impulses


Boosts metabolism

Potatoes are an excellent source of Vitamin B6; this mineral boosts your energy levels by breaking down protein and carbohydrates into amino acids and glucose.

Eating potato salad keeps you energized all day.

Reduced risk of cancer

Folate, a mineral found in potatoes, is critical for DNA repair and synthesis.

This mineral encourages DNA mutation and prevents cancer cells from forming.

Vitamin C found in potatoes contains antioxidants that prevent free radicals from damaging cells.

Weight management

Potato salad contains dietary fiber.

Daily fiber intake improves the digestive system and keeps you satiated for a long time.

Eating potato salad will prevent you from eating more calories than required to maintain healthy body weight.

Nutritional facts about Juan Pollo potato salad

Calories in potato salad depend on what ingredients you use.

Potatoes are low in calories, but adding mayonnaise, oil, butter, and sour cream increases the number of calories.

One serving of Juan Pollo potato salad contains 280 calories.

The nutrition summary is as follows;

Carbohydrates 19g (27.7%)


Fat 22 g (72.3%)


Saturated fat 3.5 g


Frequently asked questions about Juan Pollo Potato Salad

How long can you keep potato salad at room temperature?

If kept under room temperature, you should consume potato salad within two hours of preparation.

If you want to keep the salad longer, refrigerate at negative 40 degrees for a day or two, then consume.

Can I make my potato salad the day before?

You can make your potato salad a day before and keep it in the fridge.

It tastes even better when refrigerated for a day or two.

Put your salad in an airtight container and refrigerate for one week.

Is Juan Pollo potato salad a healthy meal?

Yes, but the ingredients you use to make your potato salad will dictate its health rating.

Juan Pollo potato salad contains high-fat ingredients like mayonnaise; you can substitute this with sour cream to make a more nutritious potato salad.


Whether hosting a party or preparing a meal to eat at home, a Juan Pollo potato salad always comes in handy.

Potato salad is an excellent side dish to go along with your main meals.

Try it today; substitute the ingredients however you like and enjoy creamy thick potato salad with any side dish.

Classic copycat Juan Pollo Potato Salad Recipe

Classic copycat Juan Pollo Potato Salad Recipe

Thick creamy potato salad is a delicious meal you can serve as a side dish.
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 15 minutes
Course Salad
Cuisine American
Servings 2
Calories 135 kcal


  • 1 bowl


  • 1 onions
  • 1 black olives
  • 1 onions
  • 1 Salt
  • 1 potatoes
  • 1 Water
  • 1 Mayonnaise
  • 1 Black pepper
  • 1 Sour cream


  • Wash the unpeeled potatoes and boil them in salted water.
  • Drain the water once the potatoes are tender.
  • Let your potatoes cool for a few minutes, then peel.
  • Slice the potatoes and put them on a plate.
  • Put the parsley, mayonnaise, onions, salt, and black pepper in a bowl and mix.
  • Add vinegar and cream as you mix until it’s soft.
  • Pour the mixture on your potatoes and let it rest a few minutes, then serve.



Calories: 135kcalCarbohydrates: 29gProtein: 3gFat: 1gSaturated Fat: 1gPolyunsaturated Fat: 1gMonounsaturated Fat: 1gCholesterol: 1mgSodium: 46mgPotassium: 617mgFiber: 4gSugar: 6gVitamin A: 18IUVitamin C: 29mgCalcium: 42mgIron: 1mg
Keyword Classic copycat Juan Pollo Potato Salad Recipe
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating


Godiva chocolate cheesecake Using an instant pot or oven

Freddy’s Fry Sauce Recipe