I’ve previously done a round-up of best compact 2-slice toasters. If you need four slots, you can go and just choose a 4-slice version of the same toasters, but there actually is some variety and a few options made specifically for larger batches.
- ⭐ The Best Long-Slot Toaster: Breville BTA630XL Lift and Look Touch Toaster
- ⭐ The Best Wide-Slot Toaster: Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Metal Classic Toaster
- 👛 The Budget Pick: BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster
Large Toaster Features
Like with compact toasters, I only consider models that check the following boxes:
- Four slots or two slots wide enough to accomodate four slices of bread or pastry
- Toasting that is quick and reliable
- Ability to toast bread, thick bagel halves and pastries like pancakes or English muffins
- Defrost and Reheat settings
- Shade settings to make your bread light or dark enough by applying different levels of heat
- Common features like a high-lift carriage, a slide-out crumb tray and a Cancel button
As an Amazon associate I may earn a commission from a purchase you make. This does not increase cost for you or influence my decision.
Having looked at what’s on the market today, there are two options if you want to try the best toaster all-around, and one if you want to get one that is easier on the wallet without sacrificing too much. But really, even the more expensive ones are not that expensive.
The The Best Long-Slot Toaster: Breville BTA630XL Lift and Look Touch Toaster
- Motorized carriage with push button controls
- One touch a bit more
- One touch motorized lift and look
- Adjustable browning control. Voltage- 110 - 120 volts
- LED toasting progress indicator
Like with other Breville appliances, this one is premium device. Again, it offers the same awesome features like it’s smaller brother the BTA820XL Smart Toaster — like, the ‘a bit more’ button, the volume adjustment and touch controls, — but now you can do all that and cook more bread or pastry at the same time. The outer surface is plastic, but this is necessary to make it cool to the touch and not heat up with your bread. Note that unlike the others on the list, this one is long, not wide.
- Excellent toasting
- Brilliant smart features
- Plastic exterior
The Best Wide-Slot Toaster: Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Metal Classic Toaster
- Dual control panels make this two toasters in one with smooth Brushed Stainless housing
- Custom control: 6-setting browning dials, dual reheat, defrost and bagel buttons with LED indicators
- 1-1/2 inch - wide toasting slots, Extra-lift carriage lever, slide-out crumb tray and convenient cord storage
- Instruction book included. BPA Free
- Actual unit dimensions: 11. 15" L x10. 65" W x7. 5" H
This is the professional toaster that people use in cafes: it has the signature Cuisinart industrial steel design with a retro feel, and it produces good (if not always reliable) results. It has been such a good choice that I can even recommend it alongside the premium Breville as a similarly capable option.
- Toasts evenly and well
- Looks great
- Unlike the long-slot Breville, you can use this one to cook two batches independently
- Sometimes the toast comes out too light
- Somehow even pricier than the top-of-the-line Breville
The Budget Pick: BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster
- 4 Extra-Wide Toasting Slots - Make everyone’s favorites! Four toasting slots with independent controls let you make as much toast as you need—fast!
- 7 Toast Shade Settings - Two shade selector knobs control each side of the toaster so you can find the right results for everyone’s tastes. The selector knobs range from 1-7
- Frozen, Bagel & Cancel Buttons - Easy function buttons give you perfect toasting for frozen items, bagels, and more
- Extra Lift - The levers lift toast safely into reach. One lever for each half of the toaster
- Slide Out Crumb Trays - Keep the counter clean and the kitchen smelling fresh. Dual crumb trays let you remove crumbs before they burn or mess up your kitchen
This is the large toaster to get if you’re looking for the best bang for your buck but you don’t want to just get a cheap throwaway and compromise on warranty or features. It is not the best one to get on the market, but will get the job done.
- Works well enough for everyday use
- Handsome exterior
- The cord comes out the front of the toaster
- Toasting is only good for the price
- Made of cheap-looking plastic
This is a short one, but I hope this was helpful!